I was super excited to try this mascara... And what could be a fabulous formula, my new 'it' mascara, is unfortunately bound by a terrible wand. Upon application, wads and wads of mascara were deposited all over my lashes. Literal enormous chunks left behind. If I wanted to take the time to pick all of these out - I wouldn't be looking for a 'new and better' mascara.

I loved this mascara. The formula was so much better. Applying it was easy and perfect every time. I used to recommend it to everyone that asked what I used. The Cover Girl decided to change the formula for the worse! Not lovin' it at all. Can we go back to how it used to be?!

I have used this mascara for years, unfortunately I will be switching as this product contains parabens. Parabens are hormone disrupters that affect estrogen and thyroid hormones. Parabens have been banned in the UK since 2014. Please do better for the women who wear your makeup.

Best masacara ever! I use this every day before i go to school and it never wears off! Or smudge. Its amazing, i bought it for my mom and had to steal it because of how amazing it is. It also gives off a natural effect that i really like! You should definitely try it if you like a natural look! Awesome job cover girl.

I wore this mascara for years and people always stopped to ask me what kind of masaara I had on because my lashes were so long and full. Unfortunately, I have to say good bye to this long time staple in my cosmetic bag. The new brush does not provide the same length and fullness as the old wand. It's so incredibly frustrating!!! I've tried adding several coats but still just not the same. Bring back the old brush!!! Please! Off to try other brands. Sigh.

I've used this mascara before and it has lasted me a good while. With this mascara I do not have to worry about my lashes looking clumpy. I love how the bristles on the applicator beautifully separates my lashes to make them look so bold yet natural! I highly recommend this product to anyone! #walmartcontest

I'm so confused by some of these reviews!! This was my favorite mascara for YEARS. I only stopped buying it when I began signing up for Beauty boxes and was getting a different mascara monthly. Luckily I just got this in my Walmart Beauty Box yesterday and was very pleased! The rubber bristles really help seperate lashes so you don't get any clumps whatsoever. The thickness of the brush also helps with volume so it's a perfect 2 in 1. I first got this in high school and continued to use it for years and I'm so glad I got another one. It's very simple to build up also so you can decide if you wanna do a natural look or more coats for a dramatic look (with getting clumpy and spidery). My advice is to wait around 30 seconds in between each coat. The only reason I went down 1 star is because this is not the waterproof one so there can be a little bit of transfer sometimes due to sweating, etc. other than that...perfect mascara! #walmartcontest

Not a 3 pack! Returned first one to get just one again when the description says 3 pack. So I just paid over double normal cost because I don't have time to return it again and order just one. Very frustrated. Actual mascara was great, just know you're only getting one not three.

I received this in my Walmart Trendsetter Beauty Box. I must say, that the beauty box is a steal with this being 1 of the items in the box and it is a full sized item! I love this product. It lasts just as long as waterproof mascara but without the pain of trying to get it off at bedtime. Comes right off with makeup remover or even soap (in a bind), and it doesn't smear. The look was exactly what I wanted. If you like the fake eyelash look, buy fake eye lashes... but for me this was just the right added length and looks natural. Went on very easy. It was definitely worth the 5 stars, but I do wish the applicator was curved (but that is just my personal preference).

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this product free from Influenster to test out. Unfortunately I have stick straight, short lashes and they will not hold a curl at all unless I use waterproof mascara. This mascara was not an exception since it was not waterproof.